Gayle King Challenges AI Singer’s Creator

The debate surrounding artificial intelligence in music just got a major spotlight, thanks to veteran journalist Gayle King. During a recent ‘CBS Mornings’ interview, King didn’t shy away from asking the tough questions to Telisha ‘Nikki’ Jones, the Mississippi poet behind the viral AI singer Xania Monet. King’s pointed remark cut straight to the heart of the controversy: ‘But you can’t sing!’

The Viral Moment

The exchange quickly became a viral sensation on X (formerly Twitter), with many viewers applauding King for voicing what many in the music industry have been contemplating. Xania Monet’s soulful track, ‘How Was I Supposed to Know?’, has achieved remarkable success, topping multiple Billboard charts and even securing Jones a multi-million dollar deal with Hallwood Media. This makes Xania one of the first AI artists to reach such commercial heights.

Jones, who started experimenting with AI just four months prior, explained her creative process. She feeds her deeply personal poetry into an AI music app, using prompts like ‘female soulful vocals’ and ‘slow tempo R&B’ to shape the sound. While this innovative approach has led to significant success, King’s direct challenge highlighted the core issue: ‘So in that sense, she’s not a real person,’ King stated.

Defending the Artistry

Jones defended her work, emphasizing the effort involved. ‘I still put in the work. AI is just a tool,’ she asserted, likening it to any other instrument creators might use. She further elaborated in an interview with People that her lyrics are infused with genuine emotion and soul, drawing from personal experiences like the loss of her father. Jones believes AI doesn’t replace artistry but rather expands the possibilities for creators to share their stories.

This exchange has amplified the ongoing debate about authenticity and creativity in the age of AI, particularly impacting Black women artists who have historically fought for recognition in the music industry. Even artists like Grammy-nominee Kehlani have voiced criticism, calling the trend ‘disrespectful’ to musicians who have dedicated years to honing their craft. Despite the controversy, Jones remains steadfast, stating, ‘Technology is evolving.’