While Gary Levingston found a connection with Leslie Fhima on *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10, some of the other “golden ladies” from *The Golden Bachelor* are suggesting he wasn’t entirely upfront about his intentions. It seems that even with a more mature cast, a bit of drama still finds its way to paradise.
Accusations of Playing Games
Nancy Hulkower, who was only on the show for one episode, recently appeared on the *Bachelor Happy Hour: Golden Hour* podcast with fellow contestants Susan Noles and Kathy Swarts. Hulkower claims that she and Gary had been in regular contact before filming, and their connection deepened once they arrived in paradise. She specifically recalled asking Gary about his interest in Leslie Fhima during a date, only for him to allegedly tell her he wasn’t romantically interested in Fhima and had been “waiting” for her (Hulkower).
Both Susan Noles and Kathy Swarts expressed their surprise and disappointment when Gary ultimately gave his rose to Leslie Fhima over Nancy. While many viewers saw chemistry between Gary and Leslie, Nancy, Susan, and Kathy seem to believe Gary was acting as a player, leading multiple women on.
Gary and Leslie’s Post-Paradise Connection
Gary and Leslie’s time on *Bachelor in Paradise* was cut short after they were eliminated following the very first couple’s challenge. Despite their brief stint on the show, they have reportedly continued to explore their connection in the real world. The two recently reunited for a getaway in Lake Tahoe.
While they appeared cozy in photos shared on social media, neither Gary nor Leslie has officially updated fans on their relationship status. Leslie has previously emphasized the importance of building a friendship foundation in her relationships and mentioned speaking with Gary daily, suggesting a developing connection that is still in its early stages.
What do you think about Gary Levingston’s actions on ‘Bachelor in Paradise’? Do you believe he led the golden ladies on? Share your thoughts in the comments below!