The new MTV-produced documentary “Stans,” created in close collaboration with Eminem and Shady Films, aims to explore the phenomenon of obsessive fandom through the lens of the iconic rapper’s career. However, the film largely retreads familiar ground, offering a superficial meditation on fame rather than delving into Eminem’s personal life or providing new insights for even casual fans. Despite Eminem’s massive success over the past quarter-century, the documentary leaves viewers with little more knowledge than what has already been publicly shared.
A Familiar Story, Sanitized
The documentary touches upon well-known aspects of Eminem’s life, such as his complex relationships with his mother and ex-wife, his fierce protectiveness of his daughter, and his past struggles with addiction. However, it largely omits these details, opting instead for a sanitized retelling that uses the song “Stan” as a central inflection point. The exposition from the featured fans, while intended to add color, often comes across as cringeworthy rather than insightful.
The film introduces a dozen or so interviewees, with a Frenchman named Zolt, who calls himself “Zolt Shady” and bears a resemblance to Eminem, taking center stage. The documentary chronicles Eminem’s rise to stardom, including the pivotal moment when Jimmy Iovine gave Dr. Dre a copy of ‘The Slim Shady EP,’ leading to Eminem’s signing and the subsequent success of ‘The Slim Shady LP.’
‘Stan’ Shapes Stans: Fandom Taken to Extremes
The film shifts focus around the release of ‘The Marshall Mathers LP’ and the iconic track “Stan.” The song’s narrative about an obsessive fan named Stan, who tragically takes his own life after feeling ignored by Eminem, remains a poignant commentary on idol worship. “Stan” has also influenced some of the interviewees, whose fandom borders on unsettling. Zolt, for instance, missed three months of school due to grief over Proof’s death, and when asked about the difference between himself and Stan, he noted he hadn’t killed his girlfriend.
Other fans highlighted include Nikki, who holds a Guinness World Record for the most tattoos of a single musician (31 Eminem-related tattoos as of 2021), and Katie, who has worked at Gilbert’s Lodge for over a decade because Eminem once worked there. While Eminem himself calls “Stan” a PSA against such behaviors, the interviewees’ lack of self-awareness is palpable, making their actions seem off-putting.
The Modern Relevance of ‘Stan’ and Social Media
The term “stan,” derived from Eminem’s song, has been officially recognized by the Oxford English Dictionary as an “overzealous or obsessive fan.” Social media platforms have amplified this phenomenon, creating echo chambers for “stan accounts” and fostering a false sense of proximity to artists. Eminem’s more private approach to superstardom contrasts with this digital culture, as he rarely engages with social media, sharing only what he chooses.
Despite the cultural impact of “Stan” and the modern proliferation of fan culture online, “Stans” struggles to provide a deep dive into Eminem’s personal life. While Eminem is featured, the spotlight remains firmly on the fans, whose stories, while potentially compelling to some, feel disconnected from the artist himself. The film’s failure to answer the personal and career-related questions posed by fans in its opening sequence makes it difficult to invest in the interviewees’ narratives.
A Glimmer of Hope and Missed Potential
Amidst the uneven storytelling, the documentary does offer one genuinely touching moment: the impact of Eminem’s song “Not Afraid” on inspiring several interviewees to get sober. This sequence speaks to the healing power of music and human resilience, offering respect to those who have navigated similar struggles. However, the film concludes with the documentarians asking the fans if they expected to meet Eminem, most giving uncertain answers. While one fan, Zolt, did meet Eminem in France in 2013, the overall feeling is one of missed potential and hollowness.
Ultimately, “Stans” is a mixed bag. Positioned as an introspective look at Eminem, it instead delivers an hour and a half of fans discussing his music’s impact, with ironically unhealthily attached individuals discussing parasociality. For dedicated Eminem fans seeking new content, it might suffice. Otherwise, revisiting ‘The Marshall Mathers LP’ might be a more rewarding use of time.
What are your thoughts on the documentary ‘Stans’? Did it offer new insights, or was it a missed opportunity? Share your review in the comments below!
