It’s a pattern that’s become all too familiar: President Trump engaging in public spats with Black women journalists. The latest incident involves ABC News’ Rachel Scott, and the National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ) is speaking out, demanding an end to the hostility and disrespect.
A Troubling Pattern of Attacks
Throughout his presidencies, Trump has frequently targeted Black women journalists, often labeling them ‘second-rate’ or ‘losers’ for asking tough questions. Figures like Yamiche Alcindor, April Ryan, Jemele Hill, and Abby Phillip have all been on the receiving end of his criticism. Alcindor and Ryan were frequent targets between 2017 and 2021, while Jemele Hill faced backlash after calling Trump a ‘white supremacist’ on Twitter in 2017, leading Trump to attack her employer, ESPN.
The clashes continued recently when Trump, speaking near the Lincoln Memorial, took a question from Rachel Scott. Scott asked why his focus was on projects like cleaning the reflection pond while the U.S. was involved in a war in Iran. While some interpreted his remarks as calling her a ‘bitch,’ his actual words added to a well-documented pattern.
Trump’s Remarks and NABJ’s Response
Trump responded to Scott’s question by saying, ‘You can understand dirt maybe better than I can, but I don’t allow it.’ He continued, ‘This is one of the worst reporters. She’s with ABC Fake News, and she’s a horror show. A question like that is a disgrace to our country.’
The NABJ swiftly condemned these remarks in a statement, calling for an ‘immediate end to the continued tone of disrespect, hostility and public denigration directed at Black women journalists.’ The organization highlighted that Scott’s experience is part of a larger, troubling pattern where Black women journalists are singled out, insulted, or demeaned for asking legitimate questions and holding power accountable.
NABJ President Errin Haines emphasized the significance of these attacks: ‘When Black women journalists are targeted, insulted or demeaned for asking legitimate questions, it is not only an attack on them personally – it is an attack on the role of a free press in our democracy.’
A History of Targeted Criticism
This isn’t the first time NABJ has defended journalists against Trump’s rhetoric. They issued a similar statement last September defending Yamiche Alcindor and others when Trump berated Alcindor for a question about deploying the National Guard to majority Black, Democrat-led cities. The organization specifically named Alcindor, Ryan, and Jasmine Wright as journalists who have faced Trump’s ire in recent years.
Even during a controversial appearance at the 2024 NABJ conference, Trump referred to Rachel Scott as ‘nasty’ and ‘hostile’ when she questioned him about his previous attacks on Black journalists. His response at the time was dismissive, calling her question ‘horrible’ and questioning her affiliation with ‘fake news.’
What are your thoughts on President Trump’s interactions with Black women journalists? Share your perspective in the comments below.