America’s Next Top Model (ANTM) promised to redefine beauty standards, but recent documentaries have brought its problematic past into sharp focus. As a longtime fan, watching these exposes has been a complex experience, revealing the show’s significant flaws, particularly its failure to take accountability for the harm caused to contestants.
Two Documentaries, One Uncomfortable Truth
Within weeks, two different documentaries delved into the behind-the-scenes realities of ANTM. Netflix’s “Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model” featured insights from contestants, co-executive producers Tyra Banks and Ken Mok, and judges like Jay Manuel, J. Alexander, and Nigel Barker. Meanwhile, E! network’s “Dirty Rotten Scandals” offered a critic-driven narrative, notably without input from Banks or the judges, and included commentary from controversial figures like Janice Dickinson and Perez Hilton.
While I remain a staunch supporter of Tyra Banks and believe analyzing older shows requires cultural context, the documentaries have undeniably shifted my perspective. “Reality Check,” in particular, highlighted the immense challenge Tyra faced trying to dismantle oppressive beauty standards within an industry that had victimized her. Despite the show’s controversies, it did push boundaries by casting diverse contestants and challenging industry norms, like when Tyra confronted Janice Dickinson for body-shaming a model.
Cycles of Harm: Contestant Experiences
However, the documentaries also brought to light deeply troubling incidents. In Cycle 1, contestant Ebony Haithe faced racist and colorist remarks from hairstylists and judges, with Tyra herself telling her she appeared “ashy.” The show’s producers and judges never acknowledged or apologized for the harmful language used against Ebony, who was targeted from the start.
Perhaps the most disturbing account came from Shandi Sullivan in Cycle 2. She recounted a traumatic experience of non-consensual sex with a driver while cameras rolled, a moment producers were aware of and chose to air. Despite Shandi’s tearful retelling of the event, the response from Tyra, Ken Mok, and Jay Manuel was notably lacking in remorse. Tyra claimed it wasn’t her “territory” to intervene, a statement easily refuted by her executive producer role. Jay referred to Shandi as “poor girl,” but genuine regret for the lack of protection or intervention was absent.
More Than Just Edits: Exploitation and Lack of Apology
The pattern of exploitation continued. Keenyah Hill (Cycle 4) was given a “glutton” edit, and Nigel Barker’s response to her experiencing unwanted advances was to tell her she needed to be “in control.” Joanie Dodds (Cycle 6) had four teeth extracted without consultation, and winner Danielle Evans was indirectly told to alter her teeth for industry success, only for Tyra to later admit she knew the show’s stigma would hinder her career—and did nothing about it.
Even Dionne Walters’ (Cycle 8) trauma of her mother being shot was used for a crime scene challenge. Angelea Preston (Cycles 14 and 17) was cast knowing she had engaged in sex work for survival, only to have her prize rescinded when she won. When confronted, producers and judges often justified or excused the pain caused, rather than offering sincere apologies.
- Racist and colorist language used against contestants.
- Traumatic events exploited for dramatic effect.
- Lack of support and protection for contestants in vulnerable situations.
- Minimizing or justifying harmful actions by producers and judges.
- Failure to acknowledge or apologize for past mistakes.
The most significant stain on ANTM’s legacy isn’t just its problematic edits or offensive challenges; it’s the missed opportunity for accountability. Tyra Banks, Ken Mok, Janice Dickinson, Jay Manuel, J. Alexander, and Nigel Barker were given a platform to apologize sincerely to the contestants whose ambitions were exploited. Instead, they largely offered justifications and excuses, squandering a chance to truly reckon with the show’s damaging impact.
What are your thoughts on the recent ANTM documentaries? Do you believe the show’s creators and judges should have taken more accountability? Share your opinions in the comments below!