This is a tough one. The University of Alabama has made the decision to suspend two of its student-run magazines, Alice and Nineteen Fifty-Six. One focused on women’s issues, and the other highlighted Black culture and student life. The reason? Shifting federal guidelines around Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives.
Why the Suspension? Anti-DEI Standards Cited
University leaders informed the staff of both magazines on December 1st that the school can no longer support publications based on specific demographics. This move reportedly stems from a July memo by Attorney General Pam Bondi, which advised federally-funded institutions to avoid practices the Trump administration deemed unlawful DEI measures. Specifically, officials pointed to concerns about “unlawful proxies” – criteria that might indirectly discriminate based on race or sex.
Steven Hood, the university’s vice president of student life, explained at a meeting that magazines based on demographics like these might not align with federal guidance for a public institution. Even when magazine staff pointed out that their publications welcomed students of all backgrounds, Hood stated it wasn’t enough to meet the federal requirements.
Student Reactions and University Response
The editors of the suspended magazines expressed their disappointment and shock. Kendal Wright, editor-in-chief of Nineteen Fifty-Six, called the decision “devastating but, regrettably, not surprising” given the current national climate. Gabrielle Gunter, editor-in-chief of Alice, felt blindsided, stating she believed their First Amendment rights to freedom of the press would protect them from such anti-DEI rulings.
A university spokeswoman, Alex House, clarified that the suspensions were in compliance with the law, aiming to ensure all students feel welcome in programs funded by the Office of Student Media. She also emphasized that the university “will never restrict our students’ freedom of expression.” Hood mentioned plans to launch a new campus lifestyle magazine for all students and invited the former editors to contribute.
What are your thoughts on the University of Alabama’s decision to suspend these magazines? Share your perspective in the comments below!