Andy Cohen’s Ex Reveals Their Craigslist Affair

Hold onto your hats, Bravo fans, because Andy Cohen’s past is coming out to play! Broadway star Sydney James Harcourt is spilling the tea on a passionate, year-and-a-half-long affair he had with the Watch What Happens Live host, and the details are wild.

A Craigslist Connection

According to Harcourt, who appeared on the Dads and Daddies podcast on April 28, 2026, his connection with Andy began in the most unexpected place: Craigslist. This was long before Andy became a household name, back when he was working behind the scenes at Bravo.

Harcourt recalled their first meeting at his apartment, describing the vibe as “fun.” What started as a Craigslist encounter blossomed into an on-again, off-again romance that lasted for at least 18 months. And the review? Harcourt didn’t hold back, stating, “I just knew that he was hot and man, the sëx was really, really great.”

Andy Confirms: ‘A Mad Lust Affair’

Interestingly, Andy Cohen himself addressed this past romance back in 2024. After Harcourt made a memorable shirtless appearance as a guest bartender on Watch What Happens Live, Andy dished on his SiriusXM show, Radio Andy. He admitted, “I met him many years ago and we had a mad passionate love affair — lust affair.”

Cohen confirmed the Craigslist meeting and noted the serendipity of Harcourt later appearing on his show. It’s a small world, especially in the entertainment industry!

The ‘Biblical’ Twist and Bravo Rules

Adding another layer to this story, Andy’s ex-boyfriend and former co-host John Hill revealed that he, too, had a past encounter with Sydney James Harcourt. Andy’s hilariously nonchalant response? “I do too, girl.” Talk about a tangled web!

Despite his own history, Andy Cohen is firm about his current professional boundaries. In a candid October 29, 2025, appearance on Call Her Daddy, he explicitly stated he has never slept with a Bravo star, explaining that mixing business and pleasure at this stage of his career would be “unwise.”